STR Global Unlocked with Simon Lehmann: Unfiltered knowledge for the short term rental industry

The 5 Levels of STR Companies Explained

• Powered by AJL Atelier

Share episode

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 14:19

Many property management companies grow quickly - until they suddenly hit an invisible ceiling. But why do some short-term rental businesses successfully scale to thousands of units while others struggle to grow profitably despite increasing bookings?

In this video, i explain the five key growth stages of a professional property management company - from the founder-operator managing a small portfolio to an international industry leader with more than 2,500 units.

You will learn which structures, systems, and leadership roles are required at each stage, why more than 80% of PMCs get stuck during the transition from Level 2 to Level 3, and why working harder alone is not enough to reach the next level of growth.

Resources

Stay connected:

SPEAKER_00

Most PMC founders try to grind their way to the next stage of growth. I've spent the last two decades understanding the five levels of short-term rental companies. I ran one of the largest vacation rental companies in the world. I was co-founder and chairman of Ocasa Europe and chairman of MakeConf in Australia. And today I advise more than 50 PMCs across 20 plus countries, from the Caribbean to Europe to Australia and the United States. And in that work, I've identified one point where more than 80% of PMCs get stuck. It's not a market entry. It's not scaling to 100 units. And it's not the exit. It's one very specific transition between two levels where almost every operator hits a wall. And I am going to show you exactly which one in this video. Because the truth is every level demands a break. A break with the old structures, the old tools, the old decision-making logic that you simply cannot carry into the next level. In this video, I'll walk you through all five levels of SDR companies, what tends to break at each one, and what you need to change structurally to grow into the next. And if you're sitting at one of those transitions right now and you can't quite figure out how to move past it, there is a link below this video where you can book a consultation with me directly. So let's get into it. Before we begin, a quick thank you to Pickle for supporting STR Global Unlock. Pickle is a specialist insurance provider dedicated to the short-term rental sector, helping hosts and professional operators protect their properties with coverage designed specifically for this market. We appreciate their support in advancing professionalism across our industry. Level one, the founder operator between one and 50 units. Level one is where every PMC starts. The founder operator stage.Anywhere from one to roughly 50 units, the founders is in everything. Guest comms, owner conversations, ops, pricing, the website, the bookkeeping. The business runs on the founder's personal energy. And at this scale, that's actually fine. It works. What operators at level one are most occupied with is signing their first owners and providing the business model in their local market. They're learning the trade in real time. Every booking is personal, every owner relationship is direct. The team, if there is one, is usually one or two part-time helpers and a cleaner network. The most common mistakes I see at level one: undercharging the owner because operators are afraid to lose the contract. Customizing the operating model for every single property because it feels like service. Building a complicated tech stack way too early because they think tools will save them. And hiring full-time staff before there is enough volume to support them. There is no standardization. There is no playbook. The system exists in the founder's head. So when they try to scale past 50 units, the wheels come off because they've been built as a service business, not a product business. What an operator structurally needs to move from level one to level two is a standardized operating model. A first version of the playbook. Three tiers of service the owner contract that enforces those tiers. And the willingness to say no to properties that don't fit. Without that, 50 units is the ceiling. But level two is where it gets really difficult. Let me show you why. Level two is the scaling operator stage. Roughly 5200 units. This is where the founder makes their first real hires. Usually an operations lead, a guest relationship person, maybe a part-time bookkeeper. Revenue is real, the business is no longer a side project, and there is genuine momentum. What operators at level two are most occupied with is hiring, putting out fires, and chasing growth in two or three local markets simultaneously. The owner pipeline is starting to fill on its own. The founder is still doing too much, but they tell themselves it's temporary. The most common mistakes I see at level two: hiring generalists instead of specialists because the budget feels tight, promoting from within when the situation needs an external hire with prior scale experience. Saying yes to every owner who walks through the door, continuing to operate without real KPIs, running on instinct and gut feel, and accepting a tech stack that's three or four tools duct taped together because nobody has time to fix it. What most level 2 operators get wrong and why it stops them from reaching level 3 is that they keep adding headcount linearly with units. And the founder remains the integrator across every function. The numbers might still grow, but margin starts compressing. Cash flow gets wired because working capital is expanding faster than profit. The team is busy, but no one really owns outcomes. Everything still runs through the founder, and the founder is the single point of failure for the entire business. What an operator structurally needs to move from level 2 to level 3 is a real management team with real decision rights, a single master tech system that the rest of the stack conforms to, defined KPIs with named owners, and complete shift in the founder's role. From doing the work to running the business that does the work. And this is the point I mentioned at the beginning. The transition from level 2 to level 3 is where the most PMCs get stuck. This is the part you will really want to pay attention to. Level 3 is what I call the professional PMC stage. 200 to roughly 750 units, and this is the wall. More than 80% of the PMC I see globally either get stuck somewhere in this band or quietly stall and start losing margin. The reason this transition is so brutal is structural. Below 200 units, the business runs on effort. The founder grinds, the team grinds, and the hustle covers the structural gaps. Above 200 units, hustle stops working. The business has to run on structure, not effort. And that's a complete identity shift for the founder, for the team, for the way decisions get made. Most operators try to scale by doubling the effort. It doesn't scale. The structural gaps get exposed instead of hidden, and the business stalls or starts going backwards on margin. What operators at level three are most occupied with or should be is building real management infrastructure. A finance function that's proactive, not reactive, a tech architecture that actually integrates, standardized owner contracts, multi-market operations, capital structure conversations. The work shifts from running the business to building the company. The most common mistakes I see at level three continuing to behave like a level two operator, fighting fires instead of building structure, hiring senior people, but not actually giving them the authority to make decisions. Underinvesting in finance, HR and data, the unglamorous functions that determine whether you make it to level four. And the biggest one, the founder refusing to truly delegate, hiring a COO and the second guessing every decision they make. What most level 3 operators get wrong and why it stops them from reaching level 4 is that they don't fundamentally change how the business is run. They add the org chart but keep the founder-led decision making. They buy enterprise tools but don't redesign the workflows around them. They look like a level 4 company on paper, but they still operate like a level 2, one underneath. What an operator structurally needs to move from level 3 to level 4 is a true CEO mindset. A complete org chart with real authority distributed across it. Capital sufficient to fund the next stage of growth, MA capability, and to found the fully out-of-the-day-to-day operations. Without those, the business stays inside the wall. Most operators who reach this point think the hardest part is behind them. But level four is a completely different game. Level 4 is the multi-market platform stage. 750 to roughly 2,500 units. This is where the company stops being a single market operator and becomes a real platform. Multiple markets, multiple GMs, multiple acquisition deals running in parallel, often institutional capital on the cap table. What operators at level four are most occupied with is MA and integration, capital markets, brand, multi-market complexity, and building a true central platform that supports local autonomy without losing operating discipline. The CEO is now spending most of their time on strategy, capital, and people decisions, not on operations. The most common mistakes I see at level four overacquiring without integrating, buying companies faster than the platform can absorb them, losing operating discipline as they scale because the central team can't enforce standards across markets. Cultural drift between the original team and the acquired teams. And brand confusion. Running multiple brands in multiple markets without a clear positioning strategy. What most level 4 operators get wrong, and why it stops them from reaching level 5, is that they confuse acquisition with integration. They get good at buying companies, but never good at integrating them. So they end up with a holding structure of loosely connected operations, not a real platform. That kills the multiple at exit and it caps further growth. What an operator structurally needs to move from level four to level five is world-class MA integration, a strong central platform that gives local teams autonomy on the right things and standardization on the rest. Sophisticated capital management and real talent depth. Meaning the company doesn't depend on any single executive, including the founder. Level five looks like the destination from the outside. In reality, it's a completely different world. Level five is the industry leader stage. 2,500 units and beyond, the companies operating at this level are no longer competing on the same terms as everyone else. They're capital market players, they're consolidators, they're either preparing for an IPO, a strategic exit, or they're the ones acquiring the level three and level four companies that didn't make it through their respective walls. What operators at level five are most occupied with is capital allocation, category leadership, exit preparation, and industry consolidation. The questions are different at this level. They are not how do I grow? They are what should this company be in five years and what's the right capital structure to get there. The most common mistakes I see at level five losing the entrepreneurial edge that built the company in the first place. Letting bureaucracy creep in, optimizing for the wrong metrics, chasing growth at the expense of margin, or chasing margin at the expense of strategic position. And very specifically, mistiming the exit. I've seen companies at this level wait too long, miss the market window, and sell for half of what they could have, got it 18 months earlier. What most level 5 operators get wrong is that they assume reaching level 5 means the hard work is over. It isn't. Level 5 is the level with the highest variance of outcomes. You can either build a category-defining business that goes public at a premium multiple, or you can stagnate and sell to strategic for a fraction of what you were once worth. Both are real outcomes I've seen play out at this level. What an operator structurally needs to sustain level 5 or to exit on the best possible terms is disciplined capital allocation, absolute clarity on category position, world-class talent across every function, and exit readiness, even if you're not currently planning to exit. Because the moment the right offer comes in, you don't have time to clean up the company. You either are ready or not. These are the five levels every serious SDR company moves through. And no matter where you are right now, one thing always stays the same. The level you reach is determined by your willingness to leave behind what got you to where you are today. Every operator I've ever advised, from 50 units to over 10,000, hit a moment where structures, the tools, and the decision-making logic that built their company became the exact thing holding it back. The ones who recognized that early kept growing. The ones who didn't stalled, lost margin, or sold for a fraction of what their business could have been worth. If you're watching this and you know exactly which transition you're sitting at right now, but you are not quite sure how to move past it, that's the conversation I have with operators every single week. There is a link below this video where you can book a consultation with me directly. Look at where you are, what's actually holding you back, and what it would take to get to the next level.